I was thrilled to see this book on SLJ’s best of the year. I think it deserves it’s spot. I would recommend the book widely to teens and to adults addicted to YA lit. It was one of the more surprising and unique books I read this year.
Micah is the queen of unreliable narrators, but she told you she was a liar right up front. So, it’s kind of your fault if you believe everything she says. The story happens in three parts. There are sections that happen before the brutal killing of Micah’s secret boyfriend, Zach. Zach has a public girlfriend at school (the popular, wealthy & nice Sarah) and is seeing Micah (a school misfit) on the side. There are the sections that happen after Zach’s death. Also, there are sections about Micah’s secret-filled family history. I will admit I didn’t see Micah’s BIG family secret coming, though the author built in all the details and I certainly could have. How do you handle the death of someone who was not always a great person? As rumors fly, students find out Micah was also seeing Zach. Zach’s best friend and girlfriend both try to connect with Micah recognizing that she feels Zach’s loss, but her lies get in the way. How does lying poison relationships? This book raised more questions than it answered, but it left me feeling very satisfied at the end despite that.
This would be a GREAT book discussion book. The question of how much do you believe what the narrator tells you could fill hours. I want to find someone who’s read this one to talk with soon.
Since it is written in small sections that build it’s a good book for reluctant readers, but not for those with lower reading ability because of the way you need to keep track of Micah’s lies and all the pieces of the puzzle. That is to say, this is a very complex novel in bite sized pieces, perfect for a reader who goes for quick reads but is capable of more. I’d love to give it to the Gossip Girl reader looking for a book report book. It also isn’t for readers who can’t handle ambiguity or an ending that isn’t wrapped neatly. So, unlike some books I’d say this one is for high schoolers and college kids. It really resonates for those who have been in the social hell that high school can create. It put me back in that place, though certainly I didn’t have a secret relationship with someone who was murdered. But, I did wonder where I stood with my friends and my family the way Micah does. Also, the author does not avoid sex or swearing though she does treat them with a realism that feels respectful. I’d be happy to give this one to my daughter in her teen years. 371p., 2009